MyCarOffer
Call Us Now
Comparison

MyCarOffer vs CarMax vs Carvana — Which Gets You More?

Comparing Your Car Selling Options

When it's time to sell your car, you have more options than ever. Let's compare three popular choices: MyCarOffer, CarMax, and Carvana.

Offer Amounts

**MyCarOffer** tends to offer more than national chains because we're a local dealer with lower overhead. We don't need to ship your car, process it through a corporate center, or account for national marketing costs.

**CarMax** offers competitive but typically conservative prices. Their offers are good for 7 days.

**Carvana** provides instant online offers that can be convenient but tend to run lower than local dealer offers.

Speed to Payment

  • MyCarOffer — Same day — cashier's check or bank wire upon vehicle delivery
  • CarMax — Same day if you accept in person, but may take a business day or two
  • Carvana — 2-5 business days after pickup for payment processing

    • Convenience

    All three offer convenient processes, but in different ways:

  • MyCarOffer — Free pickup anywhere in Georgia, or bring to our Lawrenceville location
  • CarMax — Must visit a CarMax location (nearest may be 30+ minutes away)
  • Carvana — Offers free pickup, but availability varies by area

    • Who Should You Choose?

  • Choose **MyCarOffer** if you want the highest offer, same-day payment, and personal service from a local dealer.
  • Choose **CarMax** if you have a CarMax location nearby and want a well-known brand name.
  • Choose **Carvana** if you prefer a fully online experience and don't mind waiting for payment.

    • Our Recommendation

    Get offers from all three and compare. We're confident MyCarOffer will come out on top — that's why we show you an estimate before you even give us your phone number. No other buyer does that.

    Ready to Sell Your Car?

    Get your free instant estimate — no contact info required.

    1
    2

    What car are you selling?

    Get an instant estimate — no contact info required.